Why is salted butter cheaper than unsalted

Let your taste buds be your guide, and always err on the side of adding less salt at once. Call us toll-free at Monday to Friday, from 9 a. For our searchable database of kitchen-tested recipes, along with household tips and expert advice, visit our website at www.

Look for our new Holiday Collection cookbook in stores and online. Sign up to receive daily headline news from the Edmonton Journal, a division of Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Edmonton Journal Headline News will soon be in your inbox. We encountered an issue signing you up. Please try again. This website uses cookies to personalize your content including ads , and allows us to analyze our traffic.

Read more about cookies here. Just judging on the flavor and the texture alone, my everyday butter on toast, I would go with butter B. And butter A is something that I would reserve for very unique applications where I want the butter to be incorporating into the flavors of a more complicated dish.

These are two cultured butters. Cultured butter is butter in which the cream has been cultured. So, culturing of butter is going to make it more aromatically complex. Typically, hallmarks of cultured butter are going to be a slight tanginess due to the acidification that happens during the culturing process, as well as some of the byproducts of that fermentation are chemicals known as diacetyl and lactones, which are really, in conjunction with each other, what we think of as butter flavor.

Originally, all butter was cultured up until about the mid 19th century. And the reason that is is the way that you get cream from milk is you would have to let it sit overnight. So, cream is a milk product in which all of the milk fat or butter fat is aggregated and floated to the top of milk. And that is just a high concentration of the milk fat or the butter fat.

But that takes time and temperature, so usually, this was done with evening milk, so after the cows were milked, it was set in a vat or a canister of some kind, allowed to cool in the evening temperatures, and in the morning, the cream had come to the top.

So this is where we get the phrase, the cream rises to the top, or if you're Irish, top of the morning, 'cause the cream is on the top of the milk. But had happened overnight is that that lactic acid bacteria that's in the environment had settled into the cream in the milk and begun that fermentation process. So all cream was fermented or cultured to some degree. So let's jump in and take a look at these two butters in front of us. Right away, butter B is jumping out to me.

It is in this molded shape and there's a pressed cow on it. This thing is adorable. That is a butter that is intended to be presented. There is there some effort and a mold that is used in order to get the butter in this format that we haven't seen on any of the other butters we've talked about so far. So this is definitely not a utility butter, this is a butter that is meant to sit on a plate. You can't look at a butter and tell whether it's been cultured or not.

Cultures are microbes. And then moving on to A, this is a presentation that we've seen before. This is butter in its block form. Coloring, we're on the slighter yellow end of the spectrum. I would say a cream or a cru on this.

There are are no flakes in it, there's no, this is not a compound butter. And again, it's a very pleasing visual presentation, but not as compact and designed as we see in butter B. I am going to start with butter A. All right, that is a nice, smooth cut. Check it for aroma. And right away, there is a very strong buttery smell that is jumping off of this sample here.

And that is a good indication that you're dealing with a cultured butter. As I said, culturing a butter increases what we think of as the classic butter flavor, and that should really be strong on the aroma. So cultured butters, when they're put out on a plate, should actually fill the room a little bit with that buttery aroma. That's nice. The texture's really good on this. It's creamy. This is a salted butter, a little heavier on the salt than what I would call a lightly salted butter.

No flakes on this, I'm not getting any crystalline crunch on this, so this would be what would you would see typically marketed as a cultured, salted butter. Okay, let's try butter B here, which I'm really curious what's going on inside this butter. In the way the butter is melting on the tongue and moving around the palate, I would say this is probably also a European-style butter.

Oh, there's some smokiness on this. I'm guessing that what this is is smoked salt on this particular butter. It's cleaning up nicely, coating the palate nicely, I'm also gonna say that this is a European-style butter.

We haven't talked about length, but this one has length. All of that is lingering on my palate. It's actually ending a little garlicky and chivey on here, so there might be quite a bit that has been added to the butter. So, let's take a look. Oh, those are pretty close, those are-- So, you can see immediately that we've gone up in price on both of these particular products.

Again, culturing adds a significant amount of money to the final product. And that is because of the amount of time and the amount of labor that is involved with culturing the cream. Some of these additional features of this butter drove the price just a little bit higher on it. These are not cooking butters, not with that price point, and these added flavors, they would get lost when you were using 'em in a sauce or in baking, so these are really butters that are intended to be standing on their own.

So, you can make butter from any mammal's milk that produces milk fat or butter fat. There is yak milk, there's water buffalo milk, I've even seen reindeer milk used to make butter. But most of the butters that you're gonna find out there that are not cow are either gonna be goat or they're going to be sheep. Looking at these two butters, right away, I notice that there is a big difference in coloration.

Butter A has a yellower hue to it than butter B, which has a white hue. This actually tells me a lot about these butters or starts to lead me to think that they might be different types of butter.

Remember earlier, when we were talking about keratin and the green, leafy pasture? Well, that keratin in cow's milk is not used by cows, so it passes through into the milk, and then their butters are some shade of yellow depending on how much keratin was in their diet. Goats, however, use all of that keratin to produce vitamin A. And so, goat's milk is always going to be this clear or alabaster white, even when it's not in its milk form.

So goat milk cheeses, goat milk butters are often an alabaster white hue. So this, on the left, I'm thinking, is probably a goat's milk. In terms of the shape and size on this, the big difference that I'm seeing is one is in a block and one is in this circular form. This probably came from a plastic tub. And so, this is bulk butter that has just been shaped by the packaging that it's in, and not printed like a traditional butter.

It may indicate that it's a smaller producer that doesn't have access to expensive packaging equipment, or it may just be that that was just a choice and easier to distribute. All right, it's a very soft, it's a very clean cut. It's probably cuts a little bit more like lard than it does like butter. The aroma is really light, like an uncultured butter, so I'm guessing that this is not a cultured butter. This has a lot of texture, though.

It melts really quickly on the tongue. Lightly salted, a little bit of butter notes. But it's a good butter. Cold butter will not spread as easily, and likely tear the bread when using it.

Sure enough, in most restaurant galleys, the majority of butter is unsalted. Pastry chefs will tell you they prefer it because it allows more precision. Apparently, salted butter contains a slightly higher water content than unsalted butter.

In cooking, again, this will not really present much of an issue as it is a small difference. With baking, however, extra water content can have an effect on how the gluten reacts and forms within your dough. In the simplest terms, salted butter contains added salt , which acts as both a flavour-enhancer and a preservative. Compared to the unsalted product, salted butter doesn't spoil as quickly and is typically less expensive.

The simple answer is that yes, it is fine to use salted butter in baking. Salted butter tastes great on toast and in other foods because the salt will bring out not only the butter flavor, but the other flavors of whatever you're eating. Bakers and chefs usually choose unsalted butter in their recipes because it's easier to manage the salt content in the dish. Most recipes that call for butter—especially baked goods and desserts—are created with unsalted butter.

It is the standard in baking and is always implied unless otherwise specified. If you do need to use salted butter in a baking recipe, omit half or all of the salt the recipe calls for. This can never be a perfect substitution since the amount of salt can vary so widely. Butter is expensive because a lot of milk is needed to produce one stick of butter, about 21 pounds of milk for a pound of butter.

There's also the fact that butter is used for many dishes, both sweet and savory, so there will always be demand, no matter the price.

According to chef and City Bakery C. Maury Rubin, it's worth it to for all bakers not just professionals to use higher butterfat butter — as long as you're not baking in mass quantity for the neighborhood. Because butter is made from animal products, it is higher in saturated fat and cholesterol compared to margarine.

If you are buying clarified butter, it will be more expensive compared to purchasing butter or margarine. One tablespoon of butter contains calories and can lead to weight gain quite quickly. What is the Healthiest Butter? The difference between salted and unsalted butter is simple: about 90 milligrams of sodium per tablespoon. Other than that, these two butters are largely the exact same from a nutrition standpoint.